It’s funny, but I never expected gender reveals to be such a divisive issue. Now, don’t get me wrong. Nobody has jumped down my throat for the decision for a surprise delivery, and nobody’s ever been caustic to me. Still, it seems that there are two very divided camps when it comes to finding out baby’s gender. The first camp seems to come from the planning angle- wanting to make sure they have specifically gendered nurseries, clothes, etc. The second camp seems to come from the surprise angle- they look forward to having that big incentive in the final stages of labor. I suppose it’s hard to be unbiased unless you’ve experienced it both ways, and even then it’s still an opinion.
I thought it might be interesting to share why I made the decision to keep the baby’s gender a secret (and why Mr. Cookie was kind enough to agree) and see what my friends think on the issue- either side. So, here are my reasons for the surprise. Of course, this in no way is meant to say I think my way is best. It is just best for me.
Decor Many on the opposite side of the debate wonder at how I can do such things as get a nursery ready and buy clothes. I’ve never been entranced by highly gendered rooms, either for babies, children, or adults. I guess it’s most important to me that a space be functional. Form can follow that. For example, given the choice of pink paisley, blue sailboats, or a mixture of bright, cheerful colors and animals, I would choose the bright colors any day. I can’t wait for the nursery to be finished and to be able to post pictures! Look at these adorable bookends I ordered:
That’s a stock photo, as we have neither the bookshelf nor the books for them yet. But how cute are they? I am in love.
Clothing Surprisingly, I have a modest amount of clothing already. Hand-me-downs and a couple personal purchases have certainly helped. I’m not too worried about the colors my child is wearing and, while I will probably buy clothes after the baby is born (or, if friends who also had delivery surprises are any indication, will receive plenty of “gendered” clothes post birth), I am okay with blues and yellows and greens. I even saw an awesome onesie in a boutique about a year back that was pink, and on the chest is said “What? Boys can wear pink too!” I kind of wanted it, even though I was not pregnant and had no reason to think I would ever actually even have a boy. I’m still a little sad that I didn’t buy it. My husband wears pink, and he looks really good in it. Why couldn’t a son? Of course, there is the excitement of gendered clothes. Don’t think that I will keep my child in gender neutrals forever! There are too many adorable sweater vests or polka dot tights to be worn. I just don’t feel like I need to have my child’s entire first year of clothing purchased before s/he is here. Look at this adorable outfit I got for the baby’s coming home:
Big Items Back when I first started teaching, there was another teacher who was pregnant. She had decided not to find out what she was having, and one of her reasons for it made a ton of sense to me. I hadn’t given it a lot of thought up until then, but that sealed the decision in my mind. Her thinking was that if you knew what you were having, people would be really tempted to buy you gender specific things- strollers, car seats, play gyms, swings, etc that you may or may not want to use with subsequent children who happened to be a different gender (she even knew people who had registered for gender neutral stuff but had been gifted very gendered stuff instead). There are some things on my registry that are labeled as “boy” items, but I think they just happened to be gender neutral by my estimation. Maybe I’m destined to have tomboys? Or girly girls who resent being surrounded by “boy” things. Probably the latter. And, that’s okay. I will take that in stride. But I doubt my newborn is going to be offended that her bib (assuming she’s a girl) has an alligator on it and comes from the “boy” bib collection.
Name I like the idea of having to come up with two names (check back when discussions have really begun in earnest and we’ll see if that’s still how I feel). Either way, the baby’s name will be a secret until birth!
Announcement Finally, and this is the reason that really clinched it for me. I am in love with the image of giving birth to the baby, having him or her placed on my chest, and having my husband announce the gender. You can bet that will be part of my birth plan (at least the announcement part- if I have a c-section I realize they won’t be putting the baby on my chest). I love the idea that Mr. Cookie will have such an important job as soon as the baby’s born. I am very excited to hear from my own husband that first bit of information about our child.
Now, all of this said, I was one of the more obnoxious commenters on facebook a couple days ago when one of my friends was going in for her gender scan. I surprised myself at how impatient I was! And, honestly, I have no idea what we’ll decide to do with the next child. Maybe since I was so adamant this time I’ll let Mr. Cookie decide next time. I know it’ll be fun either way.
So, I’m really interested in hearing from my readers- did you find out, didn’t you? If you didn’t, why not? With future children, do you plan to find out? What is your reasoning for finding out (or not)? Do you ever feel like people just “don’t get it” when you tell them your decision (either way)?